Subscribe NowTop 5 Scar Products
Which scar product took home the Editor's Choice Award? We understand how uncomfortable scars can be to live with, whatever the cause - accident, surgery, or acne. To help you fade the appearance of scars, we listed our Top 5 Scar Products. To come up with our top choices, we evaluated scores of scar product options, from over-the-counter to all natural supplements. We listed them here in order of superiority and based our research on the following criteria:
- 1) Performance*
- 2) Speed of Results*
- 3) Quality of Ingredients
- 4) Product Safety
- 5) Customer Service
- 6) Customer Feedback
- 7) Reorder Rate
- 8) Return Policy
- 9) Success Rate
TOP 5
SCARTreatments |
|||||
| Scarinex | Talsyn-CI | Kelo-cote | Revitol | H-Scars | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
| Price (1 bottle) Price (4 bottles) Best Value |
$49.95 $139.70 |
$39.95 $239.70 |
$99.99 $599.94 |
$39.95 $239.70 |
$69.95 $419.70 |
| Overall Rating | 99.40% | 82.20% | 74.90% | 70.30% | 67.60% |
| Performance* |
|
|
|
|
|
| Speed of Results* | Extremely Fast | Good | Average | Slow | Slow |
| Quality of Ingredients | Premium | Good | Average | Average | Unknown |
| Customer Satisfaction Evaluation | 99% | 80% | 70.60% | 68% | 65% |
| Safety Evaluation | Safe for Use | Safe for Use | Safe for Use | Safe for Use | Safe for Use |
| Customer Service Rating |
|
|
|
|
|
| Reorder Rate | Highest | Good | Average | Average | Average |
| Return Policy | Risk Free | Risk Free | No Guarantee | Unopened Only | Risk Free |
| Success Rate | 99.20% | 81% | 72% | 69.30% | 66.10% |
Scar Products For 2024
#1 Scarinex
Overall Rating: 99.1%
Product Claims:
Our top recommendation for a scar product is Scarinex. This product is formulated using all natural ingredients. Scarinex is a two-step scar solution: gel or cream. Scarinex incorporates three types of 100% medical grade silicone, the same ingredient that plastic surgeons and dermatologists usually recommend to help address scars. The Scarinex formula is designed to help with many different types of scars, including keloid and hypertrophic scars and those resulting from wounds, acne, burns and surgery. This product was created in a U.S. approved laboratory that is also certified by GMP (Good Manufacturing Practices), assuring the consumer that the product was made under very strict standards for quality and purity.
Value:
Scarinex can be purchased online with big savings. It offers various discount packages. For example, if you purchase two bottles, then you receive another two bottles completely free! This brings the price down to $24.95 per bottle. You can get an even a higher discount if you order three bottles, getting three bottles for free! In this package each bottle is only $23.28. Scarinex has no reported side effects and is safe for anyone, at any age. Now, that’s value!
Conclusion:
Of all the scar fading products we have reviewed, Scarinex ranks among the highest. We liked that it has a two-step solution that addresses all kinds of scars. It's formula contains 100% medical grade silicone and other natural ingredients that work very well. The manufacturer offers a risk-free money back guarantee and excellent customer service. The feedback, we found from happy customers is simply further confirmation of what we already know, that this is a great product, hence being awarded Scar Center’s #1 choice.
Read Full Review >>#2 Talsyn-CI
Overall Rating: 78%
Product Claims:
Talsyn-CI came in a close second. It had the right idea to provide the wide range of ingredients it did in its formula. It included some key ingredients including Aloe Vera and several plant oils. The manufacturer claims that this product is a proprietary blend of botanicals that help nourish the skin.*
Value:
Talsyn-CI sells for $39.95 for a 2 oz. tube. Only two units can be purchased at a time.You can save 10% on your second tube by getting the Talsyn-CI 2-Pack. It is backed by a 30 day satisfaction guarantee.
Conclusion:
Talsyn-CI was almost there with a top quality product but we felt that there were several key elements missing. Firstly, it does contain some of the top natural key ingredients known for addressing scars, however, we would have liked to have seen even more. Additionally, we would liked to have seen more positive reviews. If they addressed these issues, we felt that this could have been a real winner!
Read Full Review >>#3 Kelo-cote
Overall Rating: 73.5%
Product Claims:
Kelo-cote is intended for the management of old and new scars, including hypertrophic and keloid scars, resulting from surgery, trauma, wounds and burns and for healing abnormal scarring. The manufacturer of Kelo-cote claims that it is a 100% waterproof silicone gel product that has been tested by scientists.* It’s formula includes two chemically based ingredients Polysiloxanes, Silicon Dioxide.
Value:
Kelo-cote is sold via third party sellers online and brick and mortar stores. It sells for $99.99 for a 60 gram tube. There are no discounts or options for buying in bulk. We felt that the price for this product was expensive, compared to others similar products that are available. Our main issue was that this manufacturer makes many good claims about the benefits of this product and what it can achieve. However they fail to back up these claims with any kind of a money back guarantee. This definitely reduced its appeal for us.
Conclusion:
Kelo-cote seems to be a good product with a good reputation and offers several very positive elements. It is formulated with an excellent quality, waterproof silicone. We liked the fact that we found some good reviews on retailer sites. However, it does not contain any natural key ingredients, which is a concern to us. We also were concerned that Kelo-cote can cause irritation. This manufacturer fails to provide enough information on this, which definitely lowered the appeal for us. Additionally, we would have liked to have seen a money back guarantee so that consumers could buy with greater confidence. We would like to have perhaps seen multi-purchase price deals to reduce the inflated price for this supplement.
Read Full Review >>#4 Revitol
Overall Rating: 62.4%
Product Claims:
Revitol claims to help reduce the appearance of scars caused by acne, burns, and other factors in a natural way.* The ingredients are all natural and include Aloe Vera, Safflower Seed Oil and Vitamin C. We would like to have seen several other key ingredients in their too, such as Tocopheryl Acetate (Vitamin E) or Onion Bulb Extract. However, what they have used appears to be of good quality. Additionally, when we tested the ingredients in this product, they were as reported on the bottle.
Value:
Revitol sells for $39.95 for one bottle and $239.70 for six bottles. We felt that Revitol was more expensive than other comparable products, especially when buying more than one bottle. We were further disappointed to see that they do not offer any discounts for bulk buying options which could leave consumers paying a lot of money for this product especially if they want to use this for long periods for time. The manufacturer offers a 90 day guarantee but will not accept items back that have been opened or used.
Conclusion:
We placed Revitol in our # 4 ranking because it was almost there with a top quality product but we would liked to have seen more key ingredients, a more inclusive money back guarantee, and options for multiple purchases. Its redeeming feature, however, includes the fact that it does contain a lot of the top natural key ingredients known to be beneficial for addressing scars.
Read Full Review >>#5 H-Scars
Overall Rating: 61.5%
Product Claims:
Our #5 pick is H-Scars which its manufacturer claims to reduce the appearance of scars naturally.* We liked that it has a variety of plant oils in the their list of ingredients, but they are listed as inactive. It has homeopathic active ingredients which look good on the bottle, but when we actually visited each one, we were left wondering why some of them had been included in the first place. We would have liked to have seen more active ingredients such as onion bulb extract or aloe vera. We were pleased to see that it is formulated in the USA in a GMP listed facility.
Value:
Compared to our top product H-Scars is pretty expensive. H-Scars sells for $69.95 per bottle. At this time, we could not find any discounts from the manufacturer. There is free shipping if orders exceed a certain amount. All products come with an unconditional 90 day money back guarantee.
Conclusion:
This product contains some good plant oils in its ingredients well known to assist in skin nourishment. However, we would like to have seen some other key ingredients added into their formula. Overall though, we felt that it was a good product and the oils they used were all natural. However, we consider that it is quite expensive, especially given that we found no options to buy in bulk. For these reasons, we had to place this at the bottom of our list.
Read Full Review >>